Gilbert & Sullivan - Ruddigore / Michell, Price, Trevelyan, Opera World

Amazon.com

Ruddigore, a pseudo-melodramatic ghost story, became most famous for the moment when the portraits of Sir Ruthven Murgatroyd's ancestors spring to life and demand that he uphold the family curse of performing a crime every day. Less flawlessly balanced between score and libretto than some of Gilbert and Sullivan's works, it's a pleasurable trifle set to gorgeous music. Since this is the only version widely available, we're lucky it's so good. Vincent Price is wonderfully typecast as Despard Murgatroyd, the brother who hands over the title and the curse when Ruthven gives up hiding from his evil fate. Price can't sing--and he has a good 15 years on Keith Michell, who plays his older brother--but it really doesn't matter. He carries off his performance with supreme deftness. Unlike many G&S productions, this one is admirably free of mugging; the actors don't condescend to their material. The staging is as beautifully absurd as the plot. The chorus of professional bridesmaids are an indistinguishable unit out of a fractured fairy tale, sleeping in one bed and showing up in the middle of other people's scenes; and during a lovely but dramatically static madrigal, the cast plays croquet. Part of the Opera World series of 12 Gilbert and Sullivan operettas, produced in the early 1980s, Ruddigore is among the best in an uneven project. --David Olivenbaum

Customer Reviews:

A Horribly Good Time.......2007-07-12

I have mixed feelings about this film. On the positive side, it was kind of fun to see this send-up of hammer films, complete with Vincent Price (who surprisingly holds his own in the G&S environment). In this respect, it is an amusing halloween treat that I admittedly enjoy watching every October. On the negative side, like so many other incomplete films in this "complete G&S" series, several favorite songs are missing and some of the attempts at horrific humor fall very flat. The chorus was rather annoying to watch, and the ghosts tried to be funny instead of ghostly, which made them almost as annoying as the chorus. And yet for all of that, it is a highly enjoyable film to watch. The best scene? The opening of Act Two with the banter between Ruthven Murgatroyd and Old Adam.

Ruddigore.......2007-02-06

The scenery is excellent, novel use of old fashioned bicycles.
Keith Mitchell and Vincent Price both take superb parts.
Bridesmaids are VERY athletic ! maybe a bit too much so (and maybe not quite irritating enough with 'Hail the Bridesmaid')
Worth adding to your library.

Ruddigore.......2006-02-26

I first saw this one on PBS many years ago. My wife didn't. We really enjoy this one.

Excellent production.......2005-08-04

As a veteran of a wonderful college production of RUDDIGORE (I was one of the ghosts in the portraits, and one of the "bucks and blades" in Act I), I think the previous reviewers are all wrong.

While some of the productions in this series show serious miscasting (e.g. Joel Grey attempting Jack Point in YEOMEN), this one makes a success of the difficult business of mixing operatic singers with singing actors. Mezzo-soprano Ann Howard's Mad Margaret would be enough to make this dvd worth owning; when she's partnered in the great "It Really Doesn't Matter" patter trio with singing-actor Keith Michell and non-singing-actor Vincent Price, the result is surprisingly smooth and completely delightful.

Michell and Price are totally charming in their portrayals, and it's a treat seeing John Treleaven, who is now a prominent Wagnerian tenor, in the oily role of Dick Dauntless. Donald Adams is a little under-powered as Sir Roderic, and the contralto who sings Dame Hannah is a better actress than singer; yet when they come together for the "Little Flower, Great Oak Tree" duet, the music carries them through it successfully.

The staging of the Ghost Scene is superb: not only do the ancestors emerge from paintings (we managed this effect on the live stage in college), but statues and suits of armor also come to life.

The production is full of semi-fantasy cutaways during the musical numbers; e.g. when Robin, Rose, and Dick sing "When Sailing O'er Life's Ocean Wide," suddenly they're in a skiff out on the ocean. Some viewers find this contrived, but it's arguably better for video purposes than simply filming a set of traditional D'Oyle Carte dance moves.

Why four stars rather than five? Only because of the (minor) cuts: the overture is severely curtailed, and Dick's "I Shipped D'Ye See in a Revenue Sloop" is omitted.

Really awful production.......2004-08-30

I had looked forward to the TV production of Ruddigore and was appalled at what was done. The result was less professional than one my high school did years ago on a far less grand budget. Vital songs have been cut, and far too much effort is put into artificial, cutesy, and gimmicky stagings. It is particularly disappointing seeing how well other G&S plays in this series were done. Any fan of traditional G&S, and particularly this less well known gem, will be greatly disappointed, as I certainly was. Ruddigore deserves a much better DVD offering than this retread of a failed TV production.

DVD:

DVD

DVD